
In a change to your schedule, rugby’s Leicester Tigers will play “an Italian XV” this weekend. Why? Because the team they were meant to be up against no longer exists.
Delete Worcester Warriors, insert an invited Italian side to keep Leicester’s income ticking over. They need the money. The whole of club rugby needs it, even as Twickenham opens its gates for another round of lucrative autumn internationals. England’s suburban cauldron will be rammed with up to 82,000 quaffers and scoffers for games against Argentina, Japan, New Zealand and South Africa (6-26 November). Corporate invitees crowbarring themselves onto trains from Waterloo and into Twickenham’s ale emporium might assume all is well with rugby union.
But behind the earthy allure of England fixtures top-flight club rugby is at risk of collapse. Two of the 13 clubs who started this year’s Premiership are kaput and others are said to be teetering.

Results have been annulled, redundancies handed out and players from the two failed clubs dispersed across the 11 surviving teams. One senior figure confides that “the integrity of this year’s competition has gone out of the window.” And yet the stars of a debt-laden league trot out for an international programme enjoyed by some of society’s most affluent. When the Daily Telegraph was shifting to a digital subscription business model, “rugby and Brexit” drove the transformation.
The top division in club rugby is a separate entity from the Rugby Football Union (RFU) – and is often in conflict with it. Entrepreneurial club owners have fought running battles with Twickenham’s committees.
Premiership rugby though is guilty of hubris. As the RFU chief executive Bill Sweeney says: “We’ve known for some time this is a sport that’s been living way beyond its means and has been relying on wealthy benefactors.”

England are relatively unscathed. This weekend the country’s all-conquering women’s team are favourites to beat Canada and reach the World Cup final. In the men’s game the Guardian reported that more than two-thirds of England tickets cost more than £100, despite the team under-achieving. This month’s All Blacks match is worth more than £10 million to the RFU. But ultimately England’s success depends on the strength of the club sector.
Benefactors aren’t the only viable model. In France an independent body polices the finances of the 30 professional clubs, who are audited three times a year to earn a “licence to compete.” Each must keep 15 per cent of cost projections as a cash reserve. While the French regulate, English clubs are at the mercy of private generosity.

England’s Jack Willis was laid off by Wasps but was being pursued by several teams as the Argentina game approached. Willis told BBC Sport he’s heard of “75 per cent pay cuts” being considered at clubs.
Leicester, the reigning champions, draw 20,000 crowds but rely on philanthropy. This Saturday at Welford Road, 15 Italians will help them through another testing week.
Editor’s note: Paul Hayward’s book, England Football, The Biography, tracing the 150-year history of the team, published by Simon & Schuster, is out now.
Qatar band
The most political World Cup in history continues to generate ethical wrangles. With a fortnight to go, Ukraine asked Fifa to expel Iran for supplying military drones to Russia and Qatari organisers confirmed that 3,000 Turkish riot police will help keep order. With Russian veterans of Putin’s 2018 World Cup helping with logistics – and a joint RAF-Qatari squadron patrolling the skies – Doha has contracted out large parts of a devilishly hard project. UK police will also be present in their usual World Cup liaison role.
Meanwhile a Swiss report claimed that a large-scale intelligence operation was mounted against Fifa officials, with the help of former CIA operatives, in the run-up to Qatar being awarded 2022. The football will have to be good to dislodge the politics.

Fast and furious
One month after signing a seven-year extension to their deal with Formula One, broadcaster Sky Sports have found themselves unable to speak to the sport’s leading team. World champion Max Verstappen accused the broadcaster of “disrespect”, and his Red Bull team boycotted the broadcaster in protest at what they perceive as bias against them.
Verstappen is unhappy at Sky Sports’ pit-lane reporter Ted Kravitz saying rival Lewis Hamilton was “robbed” of last season’s title following the now infamous final laps of the Abu Dhabi Grand Prix in December last year. Verstappen said: “It had nothing to do with this weekend but this year. It has been a constant kind of digging and being disrespectful, especially from one particular person.”
The average viewership for the 2022 season is 1.7 million, up 60 per cent since the UK exclusive deal began in 2019. Having the leading team boycott your broadcasts won’t help those figures, so expect to see some reconciliation soon.
Phone alarm
Qatar’s Ministry of Commerce & Industry has rolled back requirements for football fans to install an invasive Covid monitoring app upon entry into the country. Until last week, all visitors to the FIFA World Cup over the age of 18 would have been required to install the “Ehteraz” Covid app, which requires absolute control of any device it’s installed on and raises serious concerns about surveillance abuses. Constant GPS tracking, the ability to read, write and transfer data, access to wireless and bluetooth devices, override privileges on other apps running on the devices and – perhaps most startling – control over whether the device can be turned off or put to sleep.
The app basically hands the device over to a Qatari government department. Visitors will still need to install Ehteraz if they visit a hospital or health facility in Doha, but to avoid the issue entirely Tory MP Alicia Kearns, as chair of the Foreign Affairs Select Committee, has recommended that visitors simply buy “burner” phones with no existing contacts, data or access.

Courting trouble
5 – Emma Raducanu is now looking for her fifth coach since her extraordinary US Open triumph in September 2021. Having hit a career high of tenth in the Women’s Tennis Association (WTA) rankings, she has now dropped to 75th in the space of the year. In the past two months, she has withdrawn from the Korean Open and Transylvania Open due to injury, and will miss the Billie Jean King Cup next week. Her last interim coach, Dmitry Tursunov, said he decided not to continue coaching Raducanu at the end of a trial period because of “red flags” he couldn’t ignore, but wouldn’t elaborate.
Raducanu’s off-court endorsements have flourished in the past year, with her earning a reported £18 million from the likes of Nike, Dior and Porsche among others. Unsurprisingly, she has now swapped her Dacia Sandero for a £125,000 Porsche 911 Carrera. Who can blame her? The life of a professional athlete can be remarkably short, and she has already achieved more than any female British tennis player managed in 44 years prior to her US Open victory.
↑ High…
Hayes code
Chelsea’s Emma Hayes was spotted in the stands for their match against Aston Villa, making her first public appearance since an emergency hysterectomy on 4 October. The five-time Women’s Super League winning manager’s absence doesn’t seem to have affected her team’s play, however. Since her unexpected departure, Chelsea have not lost; they’ve built a winning streak that has seen them defeat – among others – French Cup-winners Paris Saint-Germain Féminine. Interim manager Paul Green has indicated Hayes is progressing, but hasn’t confirmed her return date. With or without their manager, Chelsea show no signs of slowing down.
↓ and low
Spin cycle
The merry-go-round in top sports administration jobs has thrown the head of British Cycling from the ride. Brian Facer left his job after a series of slips. They included asking people not to ride bikes during the Queen’s funeral, agreeing an eight-year deal with Shell and the governing body contradicting its own transgender regulations. The recruitment process for chief executives in sport remains troublingly opaque.
Thanks for reading. Please share this email and tell us what we’ve missed. News tips and story ideas are welcome. Email them to sport@tortoisemedia.com.
Paul Hayward
Additional reporting by Andrew Butler, Luke Gbedemah and Sara Weissel.