Hello. It looks like you�re using an ad blocker that may prevent our website from working properly. To receive the best Tortoise experience possible, please make sure any blockers are switched off and refresh the page.

If you have any questions or need help, let us know at memberhelp@tortoisemedia.com

Culture

Society. Identity. Countries. Beliefs. Arts.

Explore

thinkin

Making sense of Pride, with Liz Moseley

What is the point of Pride? A protest, a parade, or just a month of pinkwashing? The origins of Pride are relatively well-known, at least within the LGBT community. All social justice movements evolve over time, hopefully as they help to achieve what they’re fighting for. But what, and who, is Pride fighting for (and against) now? On whose behalf does it speak? These are key ideological questions, but there are structural and institutional ones too, such as who runs Pride — globally, nationally and regionally? Where does the money go? Is anybody measuring whether Pride has an impact? Does any of that even matter? Join us for a ThinkIn to share what Pride means to you, and help us make sense of what Pride is for.  editor and invited experts Liz MoseleyEditor Christopher Joell-DeshieldsExecutive Director, Pride in London Debbie BrixeyChair of Oxford Pride and VP Members Services at InterPride

thinkin

The Rules: Democracy in Britain

Long stories short More than 50 people died in a suicide bombing in southwestern Pakistan.A 16 year-old boy was arrested in connection with the felling of the Robin Hood tree on Hadrian’s Wall.Sir Michael Gambon, who starred in Harry Potter and The King’s Speech, died aged 82. Marshalling in a new era Dan Wootton’s suspension this week as an anchor at the UK’s right-wing GB News station left many viewers baffled. His on-screen behaviour invited it (see below) but he’d already survived reports that he’d tricked or bribed scores of men – including former colleagues – into sending him nude photos and videos. Why now? Also this week, 21 potential bidders expressed an interest in buying the The Daily Telegraph including GB News co-owner Paul Marshall.  So what? The two could be connected. Wootton’s fall looks like Marshall clearing the decks in an attempt to prove he’s a respectable media owner. Wootton has been collecting Ofcom complaints since his first appearance on the channel, when he presented a fiery monologue on the “madness” of Covid lockdowns. On Tuesday he burbled and guffawed as the actor Lawrence Fox delivered a misogynistic tirade about a female journalist.  An auction for the Telegraph is expected within weeks and the stakes for Marshall – and the British media landscape – are high: Marshall wants to make GB News the centre of the next Tory leadership race.To that end he’s employed Conservative MPs Lee Anderson, Jacob Rees-Mogg, Esther McVey and Philip Davies as presenters.Owning The Telegraph would cement him as Tory kingmaker.But Ofcom, the regulator, can be expected to take a close look at GB News before allowing it. “We don’t see Paul Marshall as being a risk-free bidder,” says Dr Alice Enders, head of re search at Enders Analysis. “GB News is not making the bid, but the issue of material influence will be considered.”  The little hedgie that could. Sir Paul Roderick Clucas Marshall is fringe media’s Rupert Murdoch. Co-founder of the Marshall Wace hedge fund, his first venture in 2017 was the opinion website UnHerd – motto “Challenging the herd with new and bold thinking”. Marshall was joined at UnHerd by founder and former Times comment editor Tim Montgomerie, who resigned a year after its launch. Marshall’s next step was co-founding GB News and sticking with the channel through its early troubles (it was mocked for low production standards and Andrew Neil abruptly departed as launch anchor).  Who’s in Paul’s army? Marshall’s consortium includes the anti-Trump US Republican Ken Griffin, founder of Citadel, a hedge fund with $62 billion in assets under management. While the Telegraph’s expected asking price of £480 million would all but clean out Marshall’s £630 million net worth, Griffin brings $35 billion in personal wealth to the party.  Liberal, Actually? Described in one interview as possessing “the bushy hair and quiet, gentle manner of a character from a Richard Curtis sitcom”, Marshall doesn’t present as a determined anti-wokester. He spent most of his political life as a LibDem, working as a research assistant for Charles Kennedy, standing unsuccessfully for the party in Fulham in 1987 and backing the so-called Orange Book free-market LibDem sect that pushed the party into coalition with the Conservatives in 2010. He donated to the LibDems until 2014. Brexit through the gift shop. Marshall’s Road to Damascus went through Brussels – he fervently and financially backed the Leave campaign, persuading Michael Gove to join him. Gove’s move enticed Boris Johnson to the Leave camp and Marshall backed Gove’s short-lived leadership campaign in return. Like many Brexiteers, Marshall has recently opened a Dublin office and is married to a European – his French-Hungarian wife Sabina runs an antiques shop. The zeal of the convert. Marshall went to Merchant Taylors’ School in Northwood – motto: “producing gentlemen since 1561” – and says he loves Schumann, Fleetwood Mac, Manchester United and Jesus, worshipping at London’s Holy Trinity Brompton network of churches since 1997. Griffin is also a committed Christian. Soros giveth… Marshall’s City career led through Mercury Asset Management to founding his own firm in 1997 with £25 million from the conspiracy world’s second-most hated figure (after Bill Gates), George Soros. Marshall Wace and BlackRock often invest together – including in Rumble, a video site currently sheltering Russell Brand’s earnings. … and he giveth back. Marshall does a lot for charity but doesn’t like to talk about it. He is chairman of Ark Schools, a chain of 40 academies, and founder of the Education Policy Institute and the Marshall Institute for Philanthropy and Social Entrepreneurship.  Marshall & sons Marshall’s kids Winston and Giovanna are musicians. Winston was the banjo plucker in Mumford & Sons until he praised the right-wing journalist Andy Ngo’s book attacking Antifa and departed the band. Winston now fanboys Jordan Peterson and hosts a podcast for the Spectator, owned by the Telegraph and thus, potentially, by his father. This article was amended after publication. aLSO, in the nibs Not for EU eBay pesticides Not quite on track Feathered fiends Misinformation in Slovakia reviewed this week We’re watching: Pygmalion and Vanya We’re reading: Great Uncle Harry We’re listening to: Cousin by Wilco Thanks for reading. Please tell your friends to sign up, send us ideas and tell us what you think. Email sensemaker@tortoisemedia.com. Choose which Tortoise newsletters you receive NEW from tortoise

thinkin

Sack the leaders: are young people the answer to a net-zero future?

Young people are no strangers to activism. Several young climate activists — Greta Thunberg, Vanessa Nakate and Alexandria Villaseñor to name a few — have led protests that have gathered momentum globally. From platforming the voices of young people fighting for their futures to becoming influential climate champions, young people are at the forefront of the campaign for climate justice. Despite this,  their voices often don’t reach the upper echelons of climate governance conversations.Critics argued that youth participation at COP26 amounted to inviting “cherry-picked young people to meetings like this to pretend that they listen to us”, whilst world leaders simultaneously failed to commit to the drastic action necessary to protect the lives of young people and future generations.So, how can young people turn their activism into impactful action, when it’s often a struggle just to get their voices heard? What evidence is there to illustrate that having young people around the negotiating table makes a meaningful difference in climate governance? And, is this narrative of old versus young helpful?  editor and invited experts Ellen HallidayEditor Emily VernallCOP26 Youth Delegation

thinkin

Does British democracy work for you?

How can we improve British democracy? It’s a question that doesn’t just concern our parliamentary elections, or even elections at all – but asks we consider the full slate of opportunities available to citizens. Who has the power to change Britain for the better, and where? Why is political power so unequally distributed, and how can it really change? It concerns our representatives, yes, but also our public services: from our education and healthcare systems to our police and regulators. And, in this series on British democracy, it asks us to go to the very root of our social contract – a social contract severely broken, perhaps irreparably. This ThinkIn series will ask how to fix it.  editor and invited experts Matthew d’AnconaEditor Councillor Tim WyeBristol Green Party Councillor, Ashley Dr Ceri DaviesDirector of the Centre for Deliberative Research, NatCen Louise TickleJournalist and Reporter

thinkin

Does British Democracy Work For You?

How can we improve British democracy? It’s a question that doesn’t just concern our parliamentary elections, or even elections at all – but asks we consider the full slate of opportunities available to citizens. Who has the power to change Britain for the better, and where? Why is political power so unequally distributed, and how can it really change? It concerns our representatives, yes, but also our public services: from our education and healthcare systems to our police and regulators. And, in this series on British democracy, it asks us to go to the very root of our social contract – a social contract severely broken, perhaps irreparably. This ThinkIn series will ask how to fix it.  editor Matthew d’AnconaEditor

thinkin

Does British democracy work for you?

How can we improve British democracy? It’s a question that doesn’t just concern our parliamentary elections, or even elections at all – but asks we consider the full slate of opportunities available to citizens. Who has the power to change Britain for the better, and where? Why is political power so unequally distributed, and how can it really change? It concerns our representatives, yes, but also our public services: from our education and healthcare systems to our police and regulators. And, in this series on British democracy, it asks us to go to the very root of our social contract – a social contract severely broken, perhaps irreparably. This ThinkIn series will ask how to fix it.  editor Matthew d’AnconaEditor

thinkin

Making sense of Boris Johnson’s Conservative party, with Lara Spirit

Local elections are done but Boris Johnson’s fate is far from clear. Join reporter Lara Spirit to chew over what the results really mean for the Prime Minister — and who in his party might be compelled to move against him off the back of them.  editor and invited experts Lara SpiritReporter John McTernanPolitical Strategist; Former Political Secretary to Tony Blair Peter KellnerJournalist and Political Commentator

thinkin

Should the UK leave the Commonwealth?

The Commonwealth of Nations is home to 2.6 billion people and comprises 54 member states, most (but not all) with links to the former British Empire. The Queen has been head of the Commonwealth for more than seven decades, and Prince Charles has been agreed, in principle at least, as her successor. But as the UK considers the next chapter of the monarchy, would the Commonwealth be better off without the UK in it? Only 9% of UK trade is with the Commonwealth – despite all the talk of it being a major trading opportunity post-Brexit. With our greater understanding of the long-term impact of colonialism, is our continued involvement in the Commonwealth just an attempt to paper over the cracks caused by Britain’s imperial past, or do we still have a responsibility to be involved? editor and invited experts Jeevan VasagarClimate Editor Dr Sue OnslowDirector & Reader in Commonwealth History, Institute of Commonwealth Studies Kojo KoramLecturer at the School of Law at Birkbeck College, University of London Lord HowellFormer President of the Royal Commonwealth Society; Chairman of the Council of Commonwealth Societies

thinkin

Should we ban private schools?

To their critics, private schools are the engines of inequality which privilege 7% of UK children at the expense of everyone else. To their supporters, private schools prepare children for the top jobs in politics, law, media and business. Private education is also a booming sector: fee paying schools contribute around £13bn to the UK GDP. Solutions for reform begin with the removal of charitable status and stripping tax benefits, and end with full integration into the state system. Could the state system cope with an extra 600,000 students? How much would it cost the taxpayer?Is elitism really that bad when it comes to education, or should parents be allowed to invest in their children’s future – even if the results aren’t guaranteed? In the era of diversity and inclusion awareness, does the old public school tie still count for much? editor and invited experts Liz MoseleyEditor Fiona MillarJournalist and Education Campaigner Lisa KerrPrincipal, Gordonstoun School