Join us Read
Listen
Watch
Book
Sensemaker Daily

Compassion, not punishment

Compassion, not punishment
Mother jailed after lockdown abortion is released

A UK mother jailed in June for procuring an illegal abortion during lockdown, under a law written in 1861, has had her prison sentence reduced by the Court of Appeal.

Three judges ruled yesterday that 44 year-old Carla Foster’s original 28-month sentence should be reduced to a 14-month suspended sentence.

One judge said that it was “a case that calls for compassion, not punishment” and there was “no useful purpose” in detaining the mother of three.

Her initial sentencing last month reignited a conversation in parliament and the courts over Victorian-era laws still on the books that criminalise some abortions – despite the technical legalisation of abortions in the UK in 1967.

Clare Murphy, chief executive of the British Pregnancy Advisory Service said she was “delighted” by the decision and urged parliament to take action urgently as two other UK women accused of illegal abortions await trial. 

Photograph Getty Images


Enjoyed this article?

Sign up to the Daily Sensemaker Newsletter

A free newsletter from Tortoise. Take once a day for greater clarity.



Tortoise logo

A free newsletter from Tortoise. Take once a day for greater clarity.



Tortoise logo

Download the Tortoise App

Download the free Tortoise app to read the Daily Sensemaker and listen to all our audio stories and investigations in high-fidelity.

App Store Google Play Store

Follow:


Copyright © 2025 Tortoise Media

All Rights Reserved