The Tortoise
Covid Inquiry

Friday 4 December

The prime minister

Months of mixed messages and local lockdowns left the country bewildered. We are living in the Disunited Kingdom – where even Boris got the rules wrong at one point. Is the Prime Minister asleep at the wheel – or is he still ill?

The NHS – Part 2

Covid-19 isn’t the only killer in town. Thousands of patients have missed cancer screenings and checkups during the crisis and mental health issues have escalated. Is there a silent secondary pandemic waiting in the wings for the NHS?

Did the media fail?

There was much posturing at press conferences – but in the end the headlines were mostly the same. What went wrong with the media’s coronavirus coverage – and how could we have done better?

Women – ignored, dismissed, neglected

Men were more likely to die from Covid-19, but women had experienced disproportionate economic, social and psychological impacts. Mothers were nearly 50 per cent more likely to have lost or resigned from their jobs than fathers. Not to mention a horrifying rise in domestic abuse. Has the British government failed women?

The healthcare industry – did it move quick enough?

From vaccines to test and trace, did the healthcare industry respond adequately to the biggest public healthcare crisis of our lifetime? And how much should we fear vaccine refuseniks?

The UK’s Covid Inquiry has begun. But Tortoise couldn’t wait.

That’s why, over three days in November and December 2020, Tortoise convened a series of investigations of the key moments and decisions in a nine-month effort to control the virus that by any reasonable standard or comparison has failed. The question is: why?

Friday 27 November

The economy: CBILs and job support – was it enough?

“Whatever it takes” was Rishi Sunak’s mantra at the start of Covid. But as the crisis unfolded, the loan scheme floundered and 3 million taxpayers were excluded from government support. Did Rishi get it right?

Downing Street – Cummings, communication & public confidence

Confidence in the government’s handling of the coronavirus fell dramatically after Dominic Cummings’s Durham trip came to light. Public faith was shattered and a clear message started to muddy. How much responsibility should the prime minister’s aide shoulder for the drop in public confidence in the covid strategy?

Who was failed the most?

Far from being a great leveller, Covid attacked some people more than others – with obesity and BAME groups more likely to fall victim to the virus. At the same time, domestic violence, child abuse and demand for child protection rose quickly under lockdown but schools and social services were too often powerless to help. So were lawyers and the courts in safeguarding cases. Why did the safety net fail some of the most vulnerable in society? How should it be fixed?

What went wrong with education?

Schools were shut down and exams cancelled – only replaced by an ill-conceived algorithm. A lack of online teaching during lockdown meant the poorest children were disproportionately punished and the education gap grew. Then, in September, universities became Covid hotbeds and new students were imprisoned in their halls. And all the while the Secretary of State for Education Gavin Williamson was nowhere to be seen…

Quarantines and travel corridors – a wasted summer?

In the lull between waves one and two the government had a window in which to create an effective national test and trace system. Instead it seemed to fret for months over who could go where on holiday. What was the scientific advice behind the travel rules? Why were there no health checks at airports? And why did thousands of tracers have nothing to do?

Friday 20 November

The UK – how did it fare?

By comparison to other nations, how was the UK’s handing of Covid-19 across the year? And how did the four nations of the UK compare in their different approaches?

The lost month – what happened in February?

Was the UK too slow to react to covid? We look back at the early days of coronavirus when Britain had a three week head start on Italy. How and why did we lose it?

Following the science? Early failures of test and trace

A fateful decision was taken in March to stop testing even those with symptoms. Was this based on science or lack of resources? Who in government argued for herd immunity over lockdown and on what basis – and was that goal ever really abandoned?

Inside the NHS – part 1

There was a lack of PPE and panic at our national healthcare system being overwhelmed. But were the right decisions being made in the first phase of frontline care? Did centralised control mean ventilators were overused and important lessons learned too late?

What happened in care?

An overwhelmed sector wasn’t able to protect the most elderly and vulnerable people in society. The UN has called the number of covid care home deaths across Europe “an unimaginable tragedy.” So how did we fail our most frail?