Hello. It looks like you�re using an ad blocker that may prevent our website from working properly. To receive the best Tortoise experience possible, please make sure any blockers are switched off and refresh the page.

If you have any questions or need help, let us know at memberhelp@tortoisemedia.com

Insecurity Council

Insecurity Council

What just happened

Long stories short

  • Richard Sharp resigned as chairman of the BBC (more below).
  • The US navy said Iran seized an oil tanker in international waters in the Gulf of Oman.
  • The UK prepared to ditch a plan to scrap 4,000 EU laws by the end of the year. 

Insecurity Council

This week Russia hosted a debate at the UN on its founding Charter that included discussion of the principle of self-determination, which Putin’s army is trying to crush with high explosives in Ukraine.

So what? This isn’t the first time Russia has made a mockery of the UN. It held the rotating presidency of the UN Security Council as it trampled on the charter by invading Ukraine last year. On Monday its foreign minister blamed “the Western minority” for the fact that “tensions between major powers are at an historic high”.

Darkness at noon. Russia is free to invert reality at the UN thanks to its periodic UNSC presidency but also

  • its permanent seat on the council; and
  • its right of veto over council resolutions.

The council was set up after World War Two expressly to be easily deadlocked and unfair towards the defeated Axis powers, but not to be absurd. There’s a growing consensus that the UN and the council in particular need fundamental reform.

The catch. Russia doesn’t share that consensus. It has a veto (see above), and it has de facto allies across the Global South unwilling to join in Western condemnation of the war even as they bear the brunt of the food and fuel price increases the war has caused.

The hope. Russia did support a new rule introduced at Liechtenstein’s behest last year requiring any power using its UNSC veto to be invited to explain why to the full UN assembly. The rule binds no member state to anything but it’s a start.

The options.  

  • The Biden administration has backed a reform plan that would expand the UNSC to include permanent members from Africa, Latin America and the Caribbean.
  • African leaders in particular embraced the plan at a summit in New York last September. 
  • The UN Charter’s Article 109 allows the charter itself to be revised by a general conference of member states with a two-thirds majority in the assembly and the approval of nine of 15 UNSC members.

But there’s no mechanism to expel rogue members, nor any prospect of rogue members adopting one. In the meantime, Russia has updated its foreign policy doctrine to redefine the US as its main adversary, as in the Soviet era; and reserve the right to use its army for preventative attacks on any country deemed to threaten Russia or its allies.

Chinese whispers. Absent any hope of peacemaking at the UN, China wants to fill the breach. In an hour-long call between Ukraine’s Volodymyr Zelensky and Xi Jinping this week it was agreed that 

  • China would make efforts to broker a ceasefire as soon as possible;
  • China would send a special representative to Ukraine and “other countries” to arrange peace talks; and  
  • Ukraine would send an ambassador to China after two years without one.

The call seems to have been partly damage limitation after Beijing’s ambassador to France let slip the view that no new post-Soviet borders were set in stone; and Zelensky said afterwards that territorial compromises were off the table. But China wants to project the image of a peace broker not least to distract from its intentions towards Taiwan. It has persuaded Iran and Saudi Arabia to restore ties and invited Brazil to join a “peace club” aiming to negotiate the end of war.

Rightly or wrongly, in the vacuum left by a paralysed UN, China will have a role.


Grain glut
Two numbers to conjure with: 40,000 per cent and €156 million. The first is the increase in the amount of Ukrainian wheat imported to Bulgaria, Hungary, Poland, Romania and Slovakia in 2022 compared with the year before. The second is the amount the EU is offering to fix the problem. When Russia invaded Ukraine and blockaded key Black Sea ports, the EU lifted tariffs on Ukraine’s agricultural exports and set up “solidarity lanes” to transport goods through neighbouring countries in a rush of good intentions. But transport problems mean the produce has remained stuck, leading to a glut and a fall in prices for local farmers. Now the eastern European countries – except Romania – have imposed import bans on Ukrainian produce and are resisting criticism from the bloc. With elections approaching in Poland and Slovakia, farmers’ voices will continue to ring loud. The risk is that they drown out Ukraine’s.


Citation wars
Last week “Heart on My Sleeve”, purportedly by Drake and The Weeknd, picked up 10 million TikTok views and hundreds of thousands of streams. The problem: the artists didn’t write the song. AI did. Another problem is that tech companies are now moving at speed to build generative AI programmes to compete with OpenAI’s ChatGPT release, but they all rely on vast bodies of other people’s creative and intellectual property scraped from the internet. Governments and creative industries are being forced to move at the same pace and thorny legal disputes loom. The EU, historically an early mover on tech regulation, is seeking to add controls of AI-generated content to its broader AI regulation bill. The WSJ has an early look at new language which would require companies to disclose a “sufficiently detailed summary” of the copyrighted material used in their systems for tools like ChatGPT. Not everyone is so bothered: the Canadian singer Grimes has said she would split 50 per cent of royalties with any successful AI-generated track that included her voice.

The 100-year life health, education AND GOVERNMENT

Sharp out
Richard Sharp has resigned as chairman of the BBC after a report on his involvement in an £800,000 loan guarantee for Boris Johnson found he’d breached the code for public appointments. Sharp has always insisted he played no part in facilitating or financing the loan, but he’s quit over what he called an “inadvertent” failure to disclose his role in setting up a meeting between the cabinet secretary, Simon Case, and Sam Blyth – the distant Canadian cousin who was offering the then-PM financial help – to an appointments panel before taking up the BBC role. Not doing so was an “oversight”, he said. The BBC board thanked him and called him “a real man of integrity”. The ultimate source of the £800,000 remains unclear. Learn more about this case, and others, in our podcast series Boris Johnson: The six million pound man.

Our planet CLIMATE AND geopolitics

Miner setback
One winner of this year’s Goldman Prize for environmental activism is Alessandra Korap Munduruku – an Indigenous leader from Brazil who’s fought to keep the Anglo American mining giant out of her Amazonian home. Trained as a lawyer, Munduruku was honoured for organising a successful campaign against the company’s applications to mine indigenous territories. Anglo American eventually caved to the pressure and withdrew their applications in 2021, leaving 400,000 acres of rainforest unscathed. Indigenous lands are home to 80 per cent of the world’s remaining biodiversity and their preservation is essential fighting climate change. What worked? Letters and petitions rather than lying down in front of bulldozers. 

culture society identity and belonging

Discord leaks
Jack Teixeira, a 21 year-old Massachusetts Air National Guardsman, sat on his mother’s porch reading a Bible moments before being arrested on April 13 for allegedly leaking classified documents, his lawyers say. But an 18-page filing released by government prosecutors yesterday paints a less wholesome picture. Teixeira has a “troubling” history of making racist and violent remarks and was suspended from school in 2018 over comments about Molotov cocktails. He had “regular discussions about violence and murder” on Discord, the messaging platform where the classified information was leaked, and kept multiple weapons in a gun locker two feet from his bed. Local police denied his application for a firearms identification card in 2018 because of his behaviour. How he later obtained a top-secret security clearance that gave him access to classified documents has yet to be explained. 

Number of the day: 38 – percentage increase in visits to the NHS website sexual health clinic search tool after a bank holiday. 

Thanks for reading. Please tell your friends to sign up, send us ideas and tell us what you think. Email sensemaker@tortoisemedia.com.

Giles Whittell

Nina Kuryata

Additional reporting by Jess Winch, Catherine Neilan, Phoebe Davis and Anna Scott.

Photographs Getty Images, Goldman Environmental Prize, DCMS

Choose which Tortoise newsletters you receive